A Good Animal marks Sara Maurer’s debut, and it’s a damn good book, debut or otherwise. My thanks go to NetGalley and St. Martin’s Press for the invitation to read and review, and Macmillan Audio for the audio version. This book will be available to the public February 24, 2026.
Everett is a teenager living in a small farming community in the upper peninsula of Michigan near Sault-St. Marie. His life is almost perfect, but then the new girl arrives at school. Mary is smart, lovely and vibrant, but her dreams do not include sheep or living in the hinterlands. She wants to be an artist, and she’s talented. She figures she’ll stay for the end of high school, which won’t be long, and then she’ll head to art school out of state and shake the hay and sheep dung off her shoes.
Everett meets Mary, and Mary meets Everett.
This tender coming of age story is achingly poignant. The two fall in love; Mary hopes Everett may grow tired of that barn, and Everett hopes Mary will come to love upper Michigan. Those of us that are older and more sensible can see that neither of them will change their minds or hearts, but youth is all about hope, and the two are set on a collision course.
Meanwhile, Everett expands his knowledge of his family’s business. He invests all of his savings in a ram against his father’s advice so that he can breed sheep; but farming can be fickle, as most of us also know.
My review fails to convey the raw emotion that Maurer skillfully portrays. In addition, narrator Michael Crouch is a pitch perfect reader. I urge you to give this bittersweet novel your time and attention; you won’t regret it.









