Bad Company is the newest novel by iconic mystery writer Sara Paretsky. It’s a stand-alone, not part of her beloved Vic Warshawski series. My thanks go to NetGalley, St. Martin’s Press, and Macmillan Audio for the review copies. This book is available to the public now.
Paretsky has been one of my favorite writers for decades, so it pains me to admit that this novel didn’t do much for me. It’s not a terrible book, but not up to her usual standard. The protagonist is a former CIA agent named Lily who comes out of retirement in order to pursue a development in one of her old cases. She discovers that someone photographed her and other women at a sacred ceremony which is not to be shared publicly; the picture shows up in the media, and she is so upset that she books a plane ticket and goes off to the ends of the world to get to the bottom of this violation.
Already this is a reach, but it’s also Paretsky, so I buy the premise and move on.
Lily flies to Hayalistan, and this is a good part of my disorientation. I did a deep dive, trying to figure out where it is; I consider myself more geographically literate than most, but for the life of me, I cannot place this country. Perhaps you can guess where this is going. When all of my diligent research goes for naught, I finally skip to the end of the DRC to read the author’s note, which tells me that it’s a fictional setting. Why didn’t this occur to me? This is a novel. Authors make up locations all the damn time, and so I should have considered this sooner, but I didn’t. It would be so like this author to include educational tidbits about places and cultures that are seldom mentioned elsewhere, and so I assumed that’s what was being done here. That’s on me.
Lily is now 70, and so in place of strength and speed, she is required to use cunning in order to solve her conundrum. I’m not that much younger than this character, so you’d think I could relate, but ultimately, it feels more grim and depressing than empowering. I’ve run into this with other longtime favorite authors, the aging of the detective or other investigator to match their own, and it doesn’t do a thing for me. I suppose I enjoy escaping the aging process when I pick up a book.
Paretsky’s word smithery is in full bloom, and the underlying values that are inferred are quite similar to mine, as always. The feminist moxie is still there; but at the same time, it feels a little tired. The plot is complex, which is usual for this writer, but I had trouble following it this time.
I was lucky enough to have both the digital and audio galleys at my disposal; however, my feelings for the reader are similar to my feelings about the novel; not terrible, but also not impressive.
I have never come away from one of this author’s books feeling disappointed before; word is out that another entry into the Warshawski series will be out next year, and I look forward to getting back on track. Meanwhile, I recommend this book only to the author’s diehard fans, and even then, I wouldn’t pay full jacket price.



