“Don’t let anybody steal your marbles.”
Maud Gage Baum is one of a kind. The godchild of Susan B. Anthony, child of first-wave feminist Matilda Joslyn Gage and an indulgent, progressively inclined father, she is unhampered by many of the traditional expectations that shackled women born during the American Civil War. But though her parents encourage her to develop her mind and talents, they have little prepared her for the wider world that greets her, and when she arrives at the women’s dormitory at Cornell University, she is considered peculiar by her classmates. She is a lonely young woman, until her roommate sets her up with Frank, an eccentric, clever man whose whimsy equals her own. My great thanks go to Net Galley and Random House Ballantine for the galley, which I received free in exchange for this honest review. It will be available to the public tomorrow, February 12, just in time to be wrapped in red paper and given to the bookworm you adore.
Maud’s story comes to us from two different time periods,
one of which starts in 1871 during her childhood and moves forward in linear
fashion, and the other in 1939, when she comes to the set where The Wizard of
Oz is being filmed to fulfill her beloved Frank’s dying wish; he has asked her
to look after Dorothy. And though it
initially means gaining access to the studio through duplicitous means, Maude
befriends the unhappy but massively talented Judy Garland, and advocates for
the intention behind her character, sometimes successfully, sometimes not.
I love this book hard. It has an unusual appeal, not a
thriller nor a grab-you-by-the-hair page turner, but rather a strangely
comforting novel, one that offers us the chance to follow Maud to another time
and another place. I read several books at a time, and this one became my bribe
to myself, the reward I could look forward to after completing increments of
other books that I wouldn’t abandon, yet didn’t love as I did this one.
How many times have I reviewed a book favorably yet with the
caveat that it isn’t bedtime reading, and maybe not good for mealtime either?
Listen up. This one is good for both. It will make you appreciate your meal as
you move through the hungry years of the Depression, and as you read about poor
Judy being starved with lettuce and cottage cheese, her penalty for reaching
puberty when the studio wanted her to look like a scrawny waif. And at bedtime,
even the sorrowful passages are wonderfully hypnotic.
The love story between Maud and Frank is one for the ages,
and without Letts, who would have guessed? Midway through the story I felt the
need to know how closely the author kept to the truth, and I skipped to the
notes at the end. I am delighted to say that this writer did a great deal of
research, and she tells the reader specifically where and when she departs from
historical fact for the sake of the story.
The way that the character of Dorothy is invented, based on a string of
actual events from the Baums’ lives, is riveting, and in fact had the author
not told us otherwise, I would have assumed that much of it was made up,
because it’s almost too cool to be true.
Letts develops her characters subtly, with never a
caricature or stereotype. Though her settings are well drawn, this is a
character based book if ever I read one, and it must truly have been a labor of
love. I’ve read a dozen books between this one and the present, yet this is the
title that makes me smile.
This beautifully crafted story is bound to rank high among
the year’s best historical novels. Sweet, soothing, and highly recommended.